Plopper Law

Contesting a Will in Indiana: What You Need to Know.

can you contest a will in Indiana

Did you know that nearly 70% of wills are contested? This is often because of concerns over undue influence or if the person making the will wasn’t mentally fit. If you’re thinking about contesting a will in Indiana, it’s key to understand the state’s laws and your legal position.

In Indiana, only certain people can start a challenge against an estate. These include spouses, kids, heirs, those who have been left something, creditors, or anyone with a claim against the estate. If you’re unsure about a will made by a loved one, getting legal advice could be a smart move. It can help you figure out if you have a case and what steps to take.

Key Takeaways

  • Nearly 70% of wills are contested due to undue influence or lack of capacity.
  • Only “interested persons” can legally contest a will in Indiana.
  • Legal standing includes spouses, children, heirs, devisees, and creditors.
  • Understanding Indiana probate laws is crucial for contesting a will.
  • Professional legal advice can provide clarity and direction in estate disputes.

Understanding the Basics of Contesting a Will in Indiana

Contesting a will can be a complex and emotional process. In Indiana, it’s important to know the key elements of a will contest. This includes legal standing, common reasons for contesting, and the probate petition process. This guide will help you understand what to expect when you challenge a will.

Will Contest Process

Legal Standing: Who Can Contest?

In Indiana, only an interested person can start a will contest. An interested person is usually a named beneficiary, heir, or someone with a direct financial interest in the estate. It’s the first step in the will contest process to prove you have legal standing.

Common Grounds for Will Contests

There are several reasons to contest a will. These include:

  • Undue Influence: Saying the testator was forced or tricked into making the will.
  • Lack of Testamentary Capacity: Claiming the testator didn’t understand what they were doing when they made the will.
  • Invalid Execution: Saying the will didn’t follow the legal rules and requirements.
  • Fraud or Forgery: Saying the will is fake or was made fraudulently.

Steps Involved in Contesting a Will

Contesting a will involves several steps, starting with the probate petition process. Here’s what you need to do:

  1. File a Probate Petition: Start the contest by filing a probate petition in court.
  2. Gather Evidence: Collect evidence to back up your reasons for contesting the will.
  3. Attend Hearings: Go to court hearings where your evidence will be looked at.
  4. Seek Legal Guidance: It’s important to work with an experienced attorney, to help you through this.

Having a skilled attorney can greatly affect the outcome of a will contest. They make sure the probate petition is done right and on time.

Legal Requirements for Contesting a Will

When you want to challenge a will in Indiana, knowing the legal rules is key. These rules help make sure the process is done right and follows Indiana’s estate law.

formal probate process

Interested Persons

Indiana’s estate law says interested persons are those who stand to gain or lose from the will. This includes people who will get something from the estate, those who are heirs, and anyone who owes money to the estate. They must show how the will affects their money or personal life to start a challenge.

Formal Probate Petition

Filing a formal probate petition starts the legal challenge. This step tells the probate court you’re contesting the will. It’s wise to work with experts at this stage. They can check if your objections are strong enough for a good case.

Time Limits for Contesting a Will

You have a limited time to challenge a will in Indiana. You must file your objections within three months after the will is put into probate. Acting quickly is important to make sure your objections are looked at by the court.

Common Reasons for Contesting a Will

Challenging a will often involves several key reasons. These include claims of undue influence, doubts about the maker’s mental state, and issues with how the will was made. There are also concerns about will forgery and fraud. Let’s look at each of these reasons closely.

Undue Influence

Undue influence happens when someone close to the will-maker controls their decisions. This can lead to the will-maker making choices they wouldn’t have made on their own. If it’s proven, the will might not be valid.

Testamentary Capacity

Testamentary capacity means the will-maker could understand their actions when making the will. To show they lacked this capacity, one might use medical records and expert opinions. These show the will-maker wasn’t mentally fit.

Lack of Valid Execution

A will needs to be properly made to be legal. This means it must have the right witnesses and be notarized. If these steps are skipped, the will could be challenged for its improper making.

Forgery or Fraud

Forgery and fraud mean changing or making fake wills. To prove this, you need strong evidence that the will is not real. 

Can You Contest a Will in Indiana?

In Indiana, you can challenge a will if you have the right reasons and legal grounds. You need to show you have a valid reason for the challenge. This includes the testator’s mental state, if someone forced them, or if the will didn’t follow the rules.

The Role of an Attorney in Will Contests

Contesting a will can be complex, but having a skilled probate attorney on your side is crucial. These attorneys are experts in estate litigation. They provide legal help, making sure your rights are protected and disputes are settled fairly.

Legal Guidance

A probate attorney’s main job is to offer legal advice. They help clients understand estate litigation and check if their claims are strong. This advice is key when dealing with the complex legal steps in will contests.

Representation in Court

Having a strong legal team in court is key to winning a will contest. Attorneys speak up for their clients, showing evidence and making arguments. Their legal skills make sure the case is strong, which helps get a good result.

Mediation and Settlement

Settling disputes outside court can be better for everyone. Attorneys work on mediation to find a peaceful solution. This way, it saves time and reduces stress for everyone involved in the estate case.

Potential Outcomes of Contesting a Will

When you challenge a will, you could face different outcomes in court. It’s important to know what might happen if you’re involved in estate disputes.

Will is Upheld

If the court says the will is valid, it sticks to the original document. This means the assets get shared as the will says, making things clear for everyone. This is often the goal because it follows the person’s wishes directly.

Will is Invalidated

But, the court might decide the will is not valid. This could be because of things like pressure, not being mentally clear, or not signing it right. If this happens, the estate might go to an older, valid will if there is one. This can lead to a lot of legal trouble, changing who gets what.

Intestate Succession

If there’s no valid will, the state’s laws take over. This means the person’s stuff gets split up based on who’s closest to them. It’s key to know how this works because it can change who gets what big time. Many things can affect how a will challenge turns out, so having a good lawyer is often key.

How to Prevent Future Will Contests

To prevent will contests, make sure your will is strong, legal, and clear to everyone. By planning your estate carefully, you can lower the risk of disputes.

Proper Execution of Wills

It’s key to make sure your will is done right to avoid disputes. Experts can help create wills that follow the law. They make sure your will has the right signatures, witnesses, and follows state rules.

Regular Updates and Reviews

Keeping your will up to date is also vital. Life changes, like new family members or changes in your wealth, mean you should update your will. This keeps your will accurate and legal.

Clear Communication with Beneficiaries

Talking openly with your beneficiaries can help avoid misunderstandings and conflicts. Being clear about your will and why you made certain choices can build trust. This can help stop disputes before they start.


Contesting a will in Indiana requires a deep understanding of the state’s laws and a strategic plan. This guide highlighted the need for legal standing and the steps to contest a will. Knowing these basics is key to a fair estate resolution.

Whether you’re challenging a will or defending it, expert lawyers are crucial. Legal advice, court help, and mediation are vital in protecting your rights during probate. These services offer the support you need.

Preventing future disputes is also important. Proper will execution, keeping it updated, and clear talks with heirs can help avoid conflicts. 

needing help with will contests and Indiana estate law? At Plopper & Partners, LLP, we help you see if you can challenge a will in Indiana. We guide you on your rights to chllenge a will and create strategies for success. Book a free consultation today.

Please Share